02
February 2023
Past Event
Judicial Reform in Israel: A Conversation with Gadi Taub

Event will air on this page.

Judicial Reform in Israel: A Conversation with Gadi Taub

Past Event
Hudson Institute
February 02, 2023
Minister of Justice Yariv Levin. From his office in Tel Aviv, above the Azrieli Junction, the world does not look the same as it does on the Motzash at the junction itself. There is constant public pressure, he says, from all corners of the territory, to move forward with the reform. The public wants it, and the government will do it. We talked extensively about the reform and the criticism towards it.
Caption
Gadi Taub and Israeli Minister of Justice Yariv Levin in Tel Aviv, Israel, on January 26, 2023. (@GadiTaub1 via Twitter)
02
February 2023
Past Event

Event will air on this page.

Speakers:
michael_doran
Michael Doran

Senior Fellow and Director, Center for Peace and Security in the Middle East

Gadi Taub

Israeli historian, novelist, screenwriter, and Haaretz op-ed columnist

Key Takeaways

 

1. According to Professor Gadi Taub, a strong supporter of the judicial reform movement in Israel, the Israeli Supreme Court is usurping authority that rightfully belongs to the Knesset and government ministries. It wields a degree of influence over not just lawmaking but policymaking that is unprecedented in Western democracies.

2. This dynamic allows the majority-left-wing court to negate the views of the majority of Israelis, who vote for either right-wing or centrist politicians.

3. The current system for appointing judges insulates the Israeli judicial system from opposing viewpoints, so sitting judges can effectively appoint their own successors. The reforms that the current government seeks are in keeping with the norms of Western democracies.

 

Listen to Event Audio

Several weeks ago, the new Israeli justice minister, Yariv Levin, announced plans to reform the country’s judicial system by curtailing the very broad power of Israel’s judiciary to appoint judges, nullify laws, and otherwise regulate public life. In the view of its supporters, the reform will revitalize democracy. “We go to the polls, vote, elect, and time after time, people we didn’t elect choose for us,” Levin claimed. “Many sectors of the public look to the judicial system and do not find their voices heard. That is not democracy.” Levin’s critics have the exact opposite view. In their eyes, judicial reform is anti-democratic.

More than 100,000 demonstrators gathered recently in Habima Square in Tel Aviv to protest Levin’s plan. Many thousands more rallied in other cities throughout the country. “Now is the hour of darkness,” author David Grossman told the crowd. To help us better understand what’s going on, we have invited Gadi Taub—an Israeli historian, author, and prominent supporter of the reform—to walk us through the debate.

Related Events
03
December 2024
In-Person Event | Hudson Institute
How the Trump Administration Can Reform the Foreign Service
Featured Speakers:
Simon Hankinson
Ambassador (ret.) Tibor Nagy
Drew Peterson
Moderator:
Matthew Boyse
The Harry S. Truman Federal Building is pictured on October 8, 2024, in Washington, DC. (Kevin Dietsch via Getty Images)
03
December 2024
In-Person Event | Hudson Institute
How the Trump Administration Can Reform the Foreign Service

Join Senior Fellow Matt Boyse for a conversation with three former senior foreign service officers on the opportunities for and challenges for State Department reform during the second Trump administration.

The Harry S. Truman Federal Building is pictured on October 8, 2024, in Washington, DC. (Kevin Dietsch via Getty Images)
Featured Speakers:
Simon Hankinson
Ambassador (ret.) Tibor Nagy
Drew Peterson
Moderator:
Matthew Boyse
03
December 2024
In-Person Event | Hudson Institute
Moldova’s Euro-Atlantic Future with President of the Parliament Igor Grosu and Foreign Minister Mihai Popșoi
Featured Speakers:
Igor Grosu
Mihai Popșoi
Luke Coffey
Peter Rough
Moldovan President Maia Sandu and European Union Commissioner for Budget and Administration Johannes Hahn pose in front of the Moldovan and EU flags in Chisinau, Moldova, on May 9, 2024. (Elena Covalenco via Getty Images)
03
December 2024
In-Person Event | Hudson Institute
Moldova’s Euro-Atlantic Future with President of the Parliament Igor Grosu and Foreign Minister Mihai Popșoi

Next year the country will hold important parliamentary elections, which Russia will doubtlessly try to undermine using disinformation. To discuss recent developments in Moldova and the region, Hudson is honored to welcome Moldovan Foreign Minister Mihai Popșoi and President of the Parliament of Moldova Igor Grosu.

Moldovan President Maia Sandu and European Union Commissioner for Budget and Administration Johannes Hahn pose in front of the Moldovan and EU flags in Chisinau, Moldova, on May 9, 2024. (Elena Covalenco via Getty Images)
Featured Speakers:
Igor Grosu
Mihai Popșoi
Luke Coffey
Peter Rough
04
December 2024
In-Person Event | Hudson Institute
Alaska’s Strategic Importance for the Indo-Pacific
Featured Speakers:
Senator Dan Sullivan
Kenneth R. Weinstein
A landscape marked by the oil and gas industry, September 27, 2008, at Nikiski Beach and Cook Inlet in Kenai, Alaska. The region is considered the 'ground zero' for oil and gas in Alaska, one of the top two oil producing states in the country. Lower right is Agrium Nitrogen Operations and left of that is Conoco Phillips LNG (liquefied natural gas) Facility. (Photo by Farah Nosh/Getty Images)
04
December 2024
In-Person Event | Hudson Institute
Alaska’s Strategic Importance for the Indo-Pacific

Hudson’s Japan Chair will welcome Senator Dan Sullivan (R-AK) to give a keynote speech on Alaska’s strategic importance to the free and open Indo-Pacific. Following his address, the senator will sit down for a fireside chat with Hudson Japan Chair Kenneth R. Weinstein to discuss Alaska’s role in energy security, national security, and foreign direct investment as well as how the next administration should approach these issues.

A landscape marked by the oil and gas industry, September 27, 2008, at Nikiski Beach and Cook Inlet in Kenai, Alaska. The region is considered the 'ground zero' for oil and gas in Alaska, one of the top two oil producing states in the country. Lower right is Agrium Nitrogen Operations and left of that is Conoco Phillips LNG (liquefied natural gas) Facility. (Photo by Farah Nosh/Getty Images)
Featured Speakers:
Senator Dan Sullivan
Kenneth R. Weinstein
09
December 2024
In-Person Event | Hudson Institute
Reauthorizing the National Quantum Initiative
Featured Speakers:
Arthur Herman
Ryan McKenney
Rima Oueid
Allison R. Schwartz
(Getty Images)
09
December 2024
In-Person Event | Hudson Institute
Reauthorizing the National Quantum Initiative

Join Hudson Institute Senior Fellow and Director of the Quantum Alliance Initiative Arthur Herman and a panel of leading experts for a discussion on why NQI reauthorization matters to government, industry, and the economy—as well as the important changes that will come with the reauthorization process.

(Getty Images)
Featured Speakers:
Arthur Herman
Ryan McKenney
Rima Oueid
Allison R. Schwartz